HomeTalentPerformance management: 4 steps to go from loathed to loved

Performance management: 4 steps to go from loathed to loved

  • 8 Min Read

How can you help your employees to love their performance management systems? Kevin Campbell, Senior People Scientist, Culture Amp, gives you 4 key steps to crack performance management.

Featured Image

Scroll down to register for free to Culture Amp’s amazing new webinar series, hosted by Culture Amp’s Senior People Scientists.

Check out Culture Amp’s latest ebook, 20 essential employee engagement questions.

According to recent studies by the management consulting firm, Deloitte, company performance management systems have a negative sixty net promoter score (-60 NPS). That means that according to benchmarks performance management systems are, on average, more despised than cable companies, internet service providers, and health insurance plans.

Given this statistic, it’s easy to see why so many organizations are evaluating and rethinking their approach. The good news is that there are several easy and actionable ways to make things better-and the results are impressive.

Research shows that organizations with employees who are more satisfied with their company’s approach to performance management are

  • 1.3 times more likely to meet their financial targets
  • Three times more likely to effectively manage change
  • 3.2 times more likely to encourage risk-taking
  • More than twice as likely to innovate

Luckily, there are a few steps you can take to create a performance management system your company will love. But first, let’s explore a couple of the key challenges that you might face.

Most employees feel like their performance management systems are unfair and they fail to inspire

Recent surveys have found that less than half of employees feel like the way they are evaluated is fair or transparent. Culture Amp’s review of relevant research has also demonstrated that there are a number of unconscious biases that can lead to inaccurate reviews.

Luckily there are several straightforward steps that can be taken to ensure that cognitive heuristics like recency bias don’t hinder your manager’s ability to make accurate evaluations. We’ll talk more about that later on in this article.

Old-school approaches to performance management are usually not motivating. If anything, they can be demotivating, uninspiring, and maybe even make people want to give up. According to a review of employee polls, only 2 in 10 employees strongly agree that their performance is managed in a way that motivates them to do outstanding work.

This is important to the success of your company because employee motivation is an important element of employee engagement and employee engagement is a leading indicator of company performance.

So let’s talk about the key elements that go into making your performance management system more motivating, fair and satisfying.

The 4 things found in successful approaches to performance

We consulted academic literature, industry research, and good practice in Organizational Psychology to determine what the most important factors are.

Ultimately, we identified four factors that are found in successful approaches to performance:

  1. Fairness, transparency, and accuracy
  2. Goal alignment and tracking
  3. Developmental coaching and feedback
  4. Accountability and recognition

1. Fairness, transparency, and accuracy

It’s a common misconception that employees’ opinions about performance reviews are strictly based on whether or not they get the raise or promotion (i.e., the outcomes) they wanted. To the contrary, researchers have consistently found that the two most important factors relate to the process itself and how employees are treated.

Research on Organizational Justice gives us a better understanding of what drives employees’ perceptions of fairness and value, and how these influence employee attitudes and behaviors at work. Originally introduced by Dr. Jerald Greenberg in the 1980’s, Organizational Justice works beautifully as a scientific model for “high stakes” processes like performance management and consists of 3 key factors:

  1. Process
    • Were decision-making rules clear and consistent?
    • Were potential biases acknowledged and minimized?
    • Did I have an opportunity to voice my input?
  2. Interactions
    • Was I treated with respect and compassion?
    • Was I informed on how the process works?
  3. Outcomes
    • Did I get what I want?
    • Was it appropriate and equitable?

We’re not suggesting outcomes are not important, but rather, that bonuses, raises, and promotions aren’t necessarily the path to a performance system your people will appreciate and embrace.

2. Goal alignment and tracking

Understanding how your organization’s goals line up with the day-to-day work of individuals and the teams they are members of is a key component of creating a motivating approach to performance. One of the most robust findings in Social and Organizational psychology is that people who set goals outperform those that do not.

Organizations like Google, The Gates Foundation, and Intel all give credit to simple goal setting techniques as being fundamental to their exceptional achievements. Driving company goals is often cited as a reason for even having a performance management system to begin with.

We’re not suggesting that goals are the only element necessary to drive motivation or that motivation is the only thing necessary for high performance. However, aligning and tracking goals will go a long way to ensuring continued success for your organization. Plus, your employees will appreciate seeing the connection between their work and your larger strategy and purpose.

3. Developmental coaching and feedback

Research has shown that high-performing organizations view enabling employees to do their best work as the true purpose and objective of performance management. When this is done well, organizations see a 23% increase in company-wide satisfaction with their performance management processes. It’s for this reason that many organizations are rebranding performance management as “performance development.”

In the past, the role of managers was to be a “boss” or a “command and control” style of leader. This style clashes with today’s modern workforce and has been replaced by the manager-as-a-coach or manager-as-a-mentor model. In fact, research from the analytics firm Gartner, found that employees who report to managers who are good coaches are 40% more engaged and demonstrate 38% more discretionary effort at work.

However, developmental coaching and feedback should be a frequent, expected part of conversations – not just between managers and direct reports but also between peers and other leaders. In a 2018 study by the Institute for Corporate Productivity, researchers explored data from 234 organizations to better understand which performance management practices drive business impact. They found that creating a culture of feedback was the most critical driver of positive organizational and financial outcomes.

When people see others asking for and providing feedback, learning and growth become the norm rather than the exception.

4. Accountability and recognition

Even though the trend has been for performance management approaches to be less focused on accountability and recognition, that doesn’t mean they are no longer important. In the high-stakes world of performance, accountability and recognition are just as important as they ever were.

In 2018 Culture Amp helped companies ask over 850,000 employees: “When it’s clear that someone at your organization is not delivering in their role, do people at your company do something about it?”

Only 45% of employees agreed or strongly agreed with that question. That means more than half of the employees surveyed on our platform feel uncertain—or worse—about how performance issues are handled within their organizations. Meanwhile, recognition is frequently cited as a key driver for motivation in a number of engagement surveys and is likely to be impacted by different approaches to performance.

After all, what is a performance management system doing if it’s not holding people accountable when they need help and recognizing great work when they’ve exceeded their expectations?

At the end of the day:

Overall, creating a performance management system that people like is the key to creating a high-performing culture. It’s a move toward an ongoing, iterative cycle of:

  1. Aligning goals and expectations
  2. Providing developmental coaching and feedback along the way
  3. Giving people recognition when they knock it out of the park (or redirection when they need more help)
  4. A fair, transparent, and accurate process – which is at the center of all of this

In the past, approaches to performance-focused only on looking backward, but the future of performance emphasizes developing future success.

While old-school approaches favor command and control leadership, the next generation aligns goals but ensures people maintain their autonomy in the process.

In the past, managers got to unilaterally determine people’s fate, but leaders are now empowering feedback from peers and others in order to help identify “brilliant jerks” that “kiss up” to their managers and kick everyone else around.

Rather than just having a once a year process, organizations are enabling continuous, semi-annual, or quarterly options.

In the future, the path to high performance isn’t kept a secret. Instead, it’s part of a system that is clear and fair to everyone.

If you would like to assess the health of your company’s approach to performance check out our guide to Culture Amp’s Performance Diagnostic survey to learn more.

Register for free to Culture Amp’s webinar series, hosted by Culture Amp’s Senior People Scientists. Webinar topics include:

Follow the links to register for free to Culture Amp’s webinar series now.

Was this article helpful?

Subscribe to get your daily business insights

Related Articles

Overcoming resistance: Transforming managers into champions of employee recognition

No matter how great HR is at designing and delivering recognition programmes, they will never work without the support and ownership of your...

  • Debra Corey
  • Jan 18, 2023

Dave Ulrich: Don’t be resigned to resignation

The Great Resignation, or spike in talent mobility, should not be a surprise.  Many employees have spent the last 18+ months sequestered, often...

  • Dave Ulrich
  • Jul 11, 2022

Global talent mobility technology must power remote working policies

The global pandemic brought fundamental changes to workplaces around the world. The demand and desire for hybrid and flexible working from new hires...

  • Helen Dugdale
  • Apr 5, 2022

Looking for ways to plug your talent gap? Here's how to use a skills-based approach to do it

The great resignation, known also as the great reshuffle, isn’t a bad thing. Great opportunities come from such large-scale movement of talent in...

  • Natal Dank
  • Feb 25, 2022

A guide to workforce planning post-2020

The majority of us have never witnessed a corporate or social shift to the same degree that we have in 2020. Such drastic change will soon come to...

  • Sam Alberti
  • Jul 24, 2020

Performance management – evolution, not revolution

The reputation of the annual appraisal has taken a good kicking over the past few years. Around Christmas, the same articles about the “dreaded”...

  • Roly Walter
  • Feb 25, 2020

Designing a change ready mindset in talent

The change process in business is crucial to developing effective employees while sustaining a successful business plan. It can heavily impact how...

  • Louron Pratt
  • Dec 10, 2019

Talent 2020: What are the biggest challenges facing HR?

With a new decade on the horizon, we asked a host of HR and business experts, thought leaders and researchers what they the biggest talent challenges...

  • HRD Connect
  • Dec 4, 2019


HRD Roundtable: Combating 'Quiet Quitting'…

08 June 2023
  • E-Book
  • May 12, 2023

HRD Network Roundtable: The Retention…

15 June 2023
  • E-Book
  • May 12, 2023

Manage change and drive value…

01 June 2023
  • E-Book
  • May 12, 2023
Sign up to our Newsletter