HomeTalent AcquisitionApprentice Levy slammed for dramatically increasing business costs

Apprentice Levy slammed for dramatically increasing business costs

  • 4 Min Read

The government’s Apprenticeship Levy, which is set to raise around £3bn a year for the Treasury, has been branded nothing short of a new payroll tax.

Featured Image

The government’s Apprenticeship Levy, which is set to raise around £3bn a year for the Treasury, has been branded nothing short of a new payroll tax.

Employers pay a levy of 0.5% of their payroll with an allowance on first £15,000. Employers with payrolls of less than £3m will not pay the levy and assuming an average salary of £25,000, employers with over 120 staff will be liable for the levy.

Insititute of Directors (IoD) head of employment and skills policy Seamus Nevin said: “The chancellor cannot pretend the apprenticeship levy is anything but a payroll tax – and a considerable one which will raise £12bn over the parliament.

“At 0.5% of payroll, it will be a big hit to big employers. With the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) also saying that employers could pass the cost of the levy onto employees, the government must also be careful of the impact the levy, combined with the incoming national living wage, could have on wage growth and job creation.

“Moreover, businesses still need clarity about how they will get more out of the levy than they put in. It is a worry that the government are working on the assumption that up to one-quarter of the money collected will be spent on administration and bureaucracy, rather than the apprentices themselves.”

He said that while employers are committed to tackling the skills shortage and apprenticeships would help in that aim, the focus needs to be on quality training, not just the race to reach the targeted three million apprenticeship starts.

 

Sugar coating

EY head of tax policy Chris Sanger said the new apprenticeship levy “follows the habit of chancellors to use pleasant words to sugar coat the introduction of new taxes, as we have seen, for example, with the naming of the UK’s energy tax as the Climate Change Levy”.

He said: “This new tax, which alone constitutes over half of the tax rises announced in the Autumn Statement, requires employers to pay an additional 0.5% on their employment costs. To some this might seem very similar to a rise in employer’s National Insurance Contributions.

“However, this would breach the government’s ‘triple tax lock’ commitment and has bad connotations as increasing a ‘jobs tax’. Furthermore, this follows on from the introduction in the Summer Budget of the Dividend Tax, which was set up as a new tax rather than merely an increase in the income tax rates on dividends.

“To those paying either tax, this word-smithing is irrelevant. They will still find themselves paying more tax on income they thought was protected under the Manifesto commitment.

The Apprenticeship Levy: Preparing for the known unknowns

 

Extra burden

The CBI claimed the levy would create a sizeable extra tax burden for business and would be sure to affect many smaller companies. But the government is insistent that the thresholds would exempt 98% of employers.

Confederation of British Industry (CBI) director-general Carolyn Fairbairn said: “With the levy set at 0.5%, even those businesses most committed to training and development won’t be able to recoup their outlay, and it looks like an additional payroll tax.”

PwC employment tax partner John Harding said he welcomed the government’s commitment to investing in apprenticeships, but was somewhat taken aback that the scheme would go live as soon as April 2017.

“Despite the benefits, the cost impact for large businesses can’t be ignored. For many large businesses the 0.5% payroll levy will be far higher than the costs of the number of apprenticeships they currently offer.

“Unless larger businesses can reap the benefits of apprenticeships in other parts of their supply chain, this will simply be a payroll tax for them. When taken together with the National Living Wage and increase in auto enrolment costs, these businesses face a significant increase in their employment costs over the next few years.”

Apprenticeships have ‘deep-lying problems’ and need ‘radical reform’ to succeed

Subscribe to get your daily business insights

Was this article helpful?

Related Articles

Josh Bersin: Talent scarcity isn’t going away. It’s time to re-think jobs altogether

It’s been another tough year for HR. Even the most optimistic HR leader would admit that issues such as talent scarcity are not going away and...

  • Josh Bersin
  • Nov 9, 2023

Framework: Making the move from active to passive talent acquisition

How can organizations tap into the potential of candidates not actively seeking new roles? Some of the most valuable candidates are those...

  • HRD Connect
  • Oct 31, 2023

How talent intelligence solves the employee redeployment problem

Our organizations have a dire need for talent intelligence. According to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, organizations in 2023 are facing...

  • Alexandra Levit
  • Oct 30, 2023

Strategic hiring: How can candidate personas help you attract ideal and adaptive candidates?

Hiring the right talent is a crucial mission for any organization. In today's competitive job market, it's more important than ever for you to...

  • Jodi Brandstetter
  • Oct 27, 2023

How to improve your internal hiring ratio

Internal mobility rates have slumped from pandemic-era record highs to concerning record lows, according to research from the Josh Bersin company....

  • Janet Mertens
  • Oct 19, 2023

Blueprint: How to avoid making costly C-Suite mis-hires

C-Suite mis-hires can be an expensive mistake, affecting the bottom line alongside organizational morale and productivity. A wrong hire at this...

  • HRD Connect
  • Oct 18, 2023

How can we curtail the rise of candidate resentment?

[powerpress] The Talent Board has conducted benchmark research on candidate experience for 12 years. In July 2023, it reported candidate...

  • Benjamin Broomfield
  • Oct 18, 2023

Framework: What can make or break a C-suite executive search?

The role of C-suite executives is more than just operational oversight. Today's C-suite executive search requires HR to identify leaders capable of...

  • HRD Connect
  • Oct 3, 2023

Events

HRD Roundtable: Combating 'Quiet Quitting'…

08 June 2023
  • E-Book
  • May 12, 2023

HRD Network Roundtable: The Retention…

15 June 2023
  • E-Book
  • May 12, 2023

Manage change and drive value…

01 June 2023
  • E-Book
  • May 12, 2023