Ebay's Tom Brown shares his thoughts on Ram Charan's radical proposal to split HR
To continue reading HRD Connect content we ask that you register your details or login using your email if you are already a subscriber or member of the HRD Connect community. There is no charge to register.
Stay connected below, or sign in if you’re already a member.
A recent survey carried out by HRD Connect asked “What are your thoughts on Ram Charan’s radical proposal to split HR into two strands (HR-A for administration and HR-LO for leadership and organisation)? Respondents were divided and so, Tom Brown, VP HR International at Ebay joined us to share his thoughts.
A survey respondent said:
“I would respectfully disagree. Leadership and organisation can be found in most business functions (usually in managerial level) as well as administration. It wouldn’t make any sense to split all of the functions in these categories.”
Tom Brown was also critical of the proposal, here are his thoughts along with more comments from the survey:
HR has to evolve but Ram Charan’s proposal is stark in its delineations seeking solid definitions where ambiguity is so often to be found. Too many people in HR are not aligned with their businesses and worse often don’t understand even the basic mechanics of how the businesses they work in make money (assuming they are for-profit ventures). The lack of business, financial and strategic acumen is something we as a function must worry about and be tougher on throughout the recruitment cycle, but that doesn’t mean the prognosis leads to an effective functional vivisection.
A survey respondent commented:
“… I agree that it is very helpful, if not essential, for HR to have business experience, but I fail to see how splitting up the functions will raise the level of the CHRO. When all is said and done, compensation and benefits are what people come to work for so we are not talking about a trivial administrative matter.”
Tom Brown added:
HR must become integral to the business and use the opportunity of its vertical strength and expertise in Talent, OD and Change Management as well as its horizontal access to people and information to act in the function of a strategist not an organisational cheerleader and/or policeperson. HR is just starting to break into the vault of data science and analytics and as this information becomes more readily accessible the function will, and will have to, change. Using both functional and organisational data including the reward levers that Ram Charan seems so keen to pass to Finance will give our CEOS and leaders the ability to make better, more objective decisions around how to use the structure, capabilities, skills and people to deliver the optimal business outcomes in the short, mid and long term. It will also allow the function to help engage and develop every individual in the business using better, more intuitive tools and personalization.
A survey respondent who agreed with Tom Brown said:
“I split it out that way within my organisation now. There is no reason one head cannot oversee both, but I agree that the work needs separate teams focus.”
What's HotHRD Roundtable Report: Levelling Up Onboarding for the Hybrid World
Roundtable Report HRD Roundtable Report: Levelling Up Onboarding for the Hybrid World 5 May 20228m
HRD Roundtable Report: Levelling Up Onboarding for...
Attracting new talent is shooting up the priority list, but also proving more difficult than ever. A...View eventHRD Roundtable Report: Redefining Company Culture in Hybrid Work Environments
Roundtable Report HRD Roundtable Report: Redefining Company Culture in Hybrid Work Environments 26 May 20228m
HRD Roundtable Report: Redefining Company Culture ...
The process of redefining a company culture is a complex one. Culture contributes directly to the da...View eventLearning to win the talent war: how digital marketing can develop its people
Whitepaper | Talent Development Learning to win the talent war: how digital marketing can develop its people9m
Learning to win the talent war: how digital market...
This report documents the findings of a Fireside chat held by ClickZ in the first quarter of 2022. I...View resourceHRD Roundtable Report: Strategies For Re-Engaging The Hybrid Workforce
Roundtable Report HRD Roundtable Report: Strategies For Re-Engaging The Hybrid Workforce 5 May 20229m
HRD Roundtable Report: Strategies For Re-Engaging ...
We know hybrid working is here to stay, forcing many organisations to experiment with innovative and...View eventHRD Roundtable Report: Making it ‘Worth It’ – What We Need to Reward, Engage and Retain
Roundtable Report HRD Roundtable Report: Making it ‘Worth It’ – What We Need to Reward, Engage and Retain 3 March 20229m
HRD Roundtable Report: Making it ‘Worth It’ – What...
We know the pandemic has caused many people to revaluate their careers and relationships with work a...View eventDave Ulrich: How can business and HR leaders simplify complexity?
Leadership Development Dave Ulrich: How can business and HR leaders simplify complexity?1y
Dave Ulrich: How can business and HR leaders simpl...
HR thought leader Dave Ulrich outlines ways leaders can deal with complexity in an increasingly busy...View articleHRD Roundtable Report: Using HR Data to Inform Organisational Decision Making
Roundtable Report HRD Roundtable Report: Using HR Data to Inform Organisational Decision Making 5 May 20229m
HRD Roundtable Report: Using HR Data to Inform Org...
Historically, HR hasn’t been as effective as it could be in sharing and communicating data with wide...View eventDigital transformation investment grows but critical skills gaps remain - Coursera report
Digital HR Digital transformation investment grows but critical skills gaps remain - Coursera report1y
Digital transformation investment grows but critic...
Covid-19 has accelerated the rate of digital learning on a global scale. Coursera's latest report pr...View articleWellbeing in the hybrid workplace: how to successfully drive engagement
Employee Engagement Wellbeing in the hybrid workplace: how to successfully drive engagement1y
Wellbeing in the hybrid workplace: how to successf...
Remote working has impacted the way we communicate as a workforce, but striking the right balance be...View articleHow to create a company culture capable of empowering the modern workforce
Culture How to create a company culture capable of empowering the modern workforce1y
How to create a company culture capable of empower...
While new working patterns that emerged from the pandemic have earned a permanent spot in the w...View articleWATCH: Connection and collaboration in a hybrid workplace
Leadership Learnings WATCH: Connection and collaboration in a hybrid workplace1y
WATCH: Connection and collaboration in a hybrid wo...
Alison Noon-Jones, VP of People & Culture at Leidos UK & Europe, shares how crucial employee engagem...View articleTurbulence ahead: Why it’s time to be bold in your leadership
Leadership Development Turbulence ahead: Why it’s time to be bold in your leadership1y
Turbulence ahead: Why it’s time to be bold in your...
HRD thought leader and Hack Future Lab founder Terence Mauri sets out why the biggest risk to leader...View article
Tom Brown added:
So, much like the some of the models before, the fundamental architecture has some soundness. However, as Le Courbusier saw the house as ‘a machine for living in’ when in reality it had to be so much more, defining HR as a machine is also too simplistic. HR must slough off (in whatever way is appropriate) the administration and administrivia that has for so long been the fallback of the function and embrace new data driven strategy, but in doing so HR should not allow itself to give up other vital levers such as compensation and benefits.
Although Tom Brown has criticised the proposal, the survey analysis does shows some support contrary to Mr Brown’s view.